Gaines Street Pies

4.3 ( 553 reviews )
Checking... 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
1184 Capital Cir NE suite e, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States
+1 850-329-2141

Gaines Street Pies stands out as a must-visit pizza restaurant in Tallahassee, renowned for its authentic NY-style pizza and vibrant atmosphere. Located at 1184 Capital Cir NE, this establishment effortlessly combines quality ingredients with a friendly, laid-back vibe. Customers rave about the robust flavors and freshness of the pizzas, particularly the popular Saucy Minx, which is praised for its perfect balance of sauce and toppings. The addition of warm, garlic-infused bread knots has further solidified its status as a local favorite.

The ambiance is another highlight, featuring a chill comic book theme that resonates well with patrons, enhancing the overall dining experience. Many reviews commend the attentive staff, with Zoe receiving special mention for her service. The fast and friendly service complements the relaxed atmosphere, making it a great spot for both casual dining and quick takeout. Whether you’re indulging in the lunch special of two slices and a drink for just $8 or exploring their draft beer selections, Gaines Street Pies offers a delightful food journey. In short, if you seek a flavorful pizza experience in Tallahassee, this restaurant deserves a spot on your dining list.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Has fast service
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Serves comfort food
    • Serves late-night food
    • Quick bite
    • Serves small plates
    • Serves vegetarian dishes
    • Serves wine
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has bar on site
    • Has toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Trendy
  • Crowd
    • Good for groups
    • Popular with tourists
    • Popular with university students
  • Planning
    • Doesn't accept reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available
  • Parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking
  • Pets
    • Dogs allowed outside

Reviews For Gaines Street Pies

Andrew Sinclair
Jul 1,2025
We love the original Gaines Street Pies but this location has the exact same ingredients and quality. Same menu same flavor. Zoe the server/bartender is wonderful. Draft beer available. Small interior seating with patio as well. Fast service, cold drinks, fresh food. If this is your closest pizza spot you should be a regular.
Franklin Cheney
Jun 9,2025
Super relaxed and chill vibe/setting. Good music, comic with hero/villain theme was nice. Friendly atmosphere and connected to a whiskey bar. Tasty pizza
Al A
Apr 26,2025
Definitely the best pizza in town if you like NY Pizza. I always ask for it well done. It is so good! Also, the lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for 8 including tax.
Lauren Hess
Apr 21,2025
Best pizza spot in Tallahassee hands down. The pizza is fresh, handmade, and packed with flavor. The Saucy Minx pizza is my go-to perfectly balanced, saucy in the best way, and loaded with quality toppings. The bread knots are another must-order, super soft with just the right amount of garlic and seasoning. The service here is always on point. The staff is friendly, laid-back, and makes you feel welcome whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. The atmosphere has that cool, casual vibe that fits perfectly with the Gaines Street energy fun, a little funky, and full of personality. If you’re looking for the best pizza experience in Tallahassee, this is the spot.
Jason Whitley
Apr 18,2025
I stopped here on my way to the airport because I was craving pizza. I’m so glad I stopped! I got the special with two pizzas and a drink. I ordered both the pepperoni and the sausage. They were SO good, hot, and delicious. I’ll definitely stop back there the next time I’m in Tallahassee!
Stan Aucoin
Apr 15,2025
Great place for a good pizza. Service was quick and courteous. Our order was quick and hot. We will stop by when we are in the area.
Kim Gomez
Apr 11,2025
The vegan pizza was delicious. I enjoyed all the veggies and the cheese itself was wonderful. Coming from Miami, I had no real expectations of how great the pizza would be. Gaines Street Pies exceeded my expectations, I’ll recommend to any fellow vegetarian & vegan to come here.
Adrinna Hoh
Mar 8,2025
Okay, the best things about pizza is the crust and quality ingredients. This place has both. This is my first visit at this location but I've tried their other locations. I've never left disappointed and I'm so glad they open this location which is much closer to home. I can foresee many stops at this place before heading home. Today's visit was Friday lunch with my husband. We walked in there at 12:15 and the place wasn't too busy but quite a few take outs and a Bite Squad driver waiting for his deliveries. Employees were friendly and helpful. What did I have today? 14" pizza with two toppings - Italian sausage and mushrooms. I had coupon from Minute Magazine so I got the pizza with two drinks for 15. They also run lunch specials with no coupons needed. Pretty good deal. I need to come back to try other toppings combinations. Since it was lunch, I did not try any of the wide selection of beer they offer here. Maybe for dinner one day. They offer many craft beers and wine. Definitely a fun place to go hang out with friends or family.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Oriental Palace
(109 review)
Oriental Palace
  • 9 1/2 N Vine St, Glenwood, IA 51534, United States
restaurant
+1 712-527-5901
Twin Oaks BBQ
(740 review)
Twin Oaks BBQ
  • 2618 Norwich St, Brunswick, GA 31520, United States
Barbecue restaurant
+1 912-265-3131
Grandma's Secret
(543 review)
Grandma's Secret
  • 50 E Dania Beach Blvd, Dania Beach, FL 33004, United States
Uzbeki restaurant
+1 954-639-7038
The Best Indian & Nepalese - NAMASTE RESTAURANT & BAR
(867 review)
The Best Indian & Nepalese - NAMASTE RESTAURANT & BAR
  • 2101 Columbia Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States
indian restaurant
+1 717-208-7009
Bud's Korner Kitchen
(408 review)
Bud's Korner Kitchen
  • 3186 US-70, Morganton, NC 28655, United States
American restaurant
+1 828-433-6580
Mohawk Restaurant
(777 review)
Mohawk Restaurant
  • 136726 US-97, Crescent, OR 97733, United States
american restaurant
+1 541-433-5277
Home Restaurant
(831 review)
Home Restaurant
  • 2801 10th Ave NE #11, Salmon Arm, BC V1E 2S3, Canada
Restaurant
+1 250-832-9991
Amore Pizza
(599 review)
Amore Pizza
  • 450 St Francois St, Florissant, MO 63031, United States
pizza restaurant
+1 314-274-8100
The Lone Star Ranch House
(355 review)
The Lone Star Ranch House
  • 8807 Ahtanum Rd, Yakima, WA 98903, United States
American restaurant
Tortas Diego
(1236 review)
Tortas Diego
  • Las Fuentes, C.Comercial Otay, Otay Constituyentes, 22425 Tijuana, B.C., Mexico
mexican torta restaurant
+52 664 623 1845